Petoskey eats at the meeting point of a resort past and a farm present: whitefish and perch from Little Traverse Bay, cherries and morels from the woods and orchards of northern Michigan, and fudge, always fudge, for the walk home. The towns dining centre is the Gaslight District downtown, where the Hotel Perry has fed travellers since 1899 and Kilwins has made chocolate since 1947. The mushroom houses in the title are not a restaurant at all. They are the hobbit like stone cottages of Earl Young in neighbouring Charlevoix, and they belong in a food trip because the drive to see them passes the farm stands and orchards that stock every kitchen in Petoskey. Sequence it as hotel dining and pub food downtown, a mushroom house and farm stand loop, and Kilwins last, every day.
Quick Facts
- Where: Petoskey, Michigan, on Little Traverse Bay, an inlet of Lake Michigan, in the northwestern Lower Peninsula
- Hotel Perry: 100 Lewis Street, open since 1899 and a member of Historic Hotels of America. Per its own site it is the only hotel in downtown Petoskey, with dining on site including the H.O. Rose Dining Room and the Noggin Room Pub
- The Noggin Room: The Perrys lower level pub, created in the renovations of the early 1960s and long known as the locals room, serving pub food and Staffords seafood chowder under the hotels front porch
- Kilwins Petoskey: 316 Howard Street. Kilwins was founded in Petoskey in 1947, still makes its Heritage Chocolate and fudge here, and sells Original Recipe Ice Cream, hand crafted fudge and caramel apples, with confections made in each stores open kitchen
- The mushroom houses: The Earl Young houses in Charlevoix, about 15 miles south, stone cottages with wavy thatched style roofs built from local boulders across the middle of the twentieth century
- Best base: Downtown Petoskey, walking distance from the Gaslight District, the Perry and the bayfront
Why does the Hotel Perry anchor the food trip?
Because it has been feeding this town longer than anything else still standing. The Perry opened in 1899 as one of some 20 luxury resort hotels in Petoskey, and per its own account it is the last of them still operating, as well as the only hotel in the downtown itself. Its dining works on three levels, which is the correct structure for a resort town day. Breakfast is the formal meal, in the H.O. Rose Dining Room, the bay facing room where the hotel has always done its white tablecloth work. The Perry Porch, open in season from late spring, is the lunch move: a terrace table, a salad and soup, and the bay in front of you. Dinner splits the difference. Eat in the dining room on the one dressed up night, and eat in the Noggin Room on every other night.
The Noggin Room deserves its own paragraph because it is where Petoskey actually eats. It sits in the lower level of the hotel, partly beneath the grand front porch, and was created when the hotel was renovated after its purchase in 1961. Staffords, the hospitality family behind the Perry, describes it as the relaxing alternative to the formal dining room upstairs, and locals adopted it accordingly, especially out of season. The menu is pub food done by a serious kitchen: burgers, sandwiches, and the Staffords seafood chowder with shrimp, scallops and clams that appears across the groups menus. In summer there is live music. In winter it is the warm room at the centre of a cold town. Either way, it is the first dinner to book and the last bar to leave.
What are the mushroom houses, and why are they in a food guide?
Charlevoix, the next town south, holds one of the strangest architectural collections in America: more than two dozen stone houses built by Earl Young, a local realtor and self taught builder, from the 1910s to the 1950s. Young built with boulders gathered from Lake Michigan and the surrounding fields, topped the houses with undulating roofs that look thatched, and made doors, chimneys and windows deliberately uneven, so the houses read as dwellings for gnomes or hobbits decades before those words were famous. They are private homes, viewed from the street, and a slow drive or walk past them in the Boulder Park neighbourhood and along Park Avenue is the regions best free show.
The food logic is the road. The drive between Petoskey and Charlevoix, and the farm country behind both towns, is orchard and farm stand territory: cherries in July, apples in autumn, sweet corn, morel mushrooms in the spring woods, and the maple and honey of a short northern season. Petoskey kitchens cook this hinterland all year, preserved, frozen and celebrated in season, so the mushroom house loop is how you meet the supply chain. Go in the morning, stop at every stand that is open, and bring the cherries or the pie back for the afternoon. For another Michigan free pairing, the farm stands explain the menus at Palette Bistro and the other bay view dining rooms back in Petoskey better than any review can.
Where does Kilwins fit?
At the end of every day, by design. Kilwins began in Petoskey in 1947, when Don and Katy Kilwin opened a candy and ice cream shop built on recipes Don had learned as a young baker, and the company still runs its chocolate kitchen in Petoskey, making Heritage Chocolate here for a national family of stores. The Petoskey shop on Howard Street, in the Gaslight District, is the original idea in its original town: fudge paddled on marble in the open kitchen where you can watch, caramel apples dipped to order, truffles and brittle behind glass, and the Original Recipe Ice Cream in a cone for the walk. Mackinac Island fudge is the famous Michigan sweet, but Petoskey makes its own claim, older and quieter, and a warm evening line at Kilwins is as much a town ritual as the sunset over the bay. Buy the fudge boxed for travel and eat the ice cream now. That order matters.
What else should go on the table?
The bay and the seasons. Great Lakes whitefish is the standing local fish, mild and firm, served broiled, planked or in chowder, and perch and walleye join it across downtown menus. Morels are the spring event, hunted in the woods of Emmet County and priced like treasure for a few weeks. Cherries, from the orchards that run south toward Traverse City, take over in July, in pies, salads and sauces. The rest of the Gaslight District fills the gaps: Julienne Tomatoes for the cafe lunch the whole town recommends, City Park Grill, the 1901 dining room where local history ties Ernest Hemingway to a bar stool from his summers on nearby Walloon Lake, and the coffee and bakery counters for the morning. For a different American resort town food pattern, compare our Staunton, Virginia food guide, and for the small town bakery and chocolate pairing done the Pennsylvania way, our Lititz eating guide.
Two days, sequenced
Day one: breakfast in the H.O. Rose Dining Room at the Perry, a Gaslight District morning, lunch on the Perry Porch in season or at a Mitchell Street cafe out of season, the bayfront and the breakwater in the afternoon, and dinner in the Noggin Room with the seafood chowder first. Kilwins for the walk home. Day two: coffee and a bakery stop, the drive south to Charlevoix for the mushroom houses, farm stands on the way back with cherries or apples depending on the month, a whitefish dinner at a bay view table, and Kilwins again, because nobody in Petoskey only goes once. In winter the same plan works with the porch swapped for a window seat and the bay frozen white outside it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What food is Petoskey known for?
Great Lakes whitefish, northern Michigan cherries and morels in season, and Kilwins fudge and chocolate, made in Petoskey since 1947. The Hotel Perrys dining rooms, open since 1899, are the towns historic centre of eating.
Can I go inside the mushroom houses?
No. The Earl Young houses in Charlevoix are private homes. View them from the street on a slow drive or walk, photograph from the pavement, and leave the gardens and doors to the people who live there.
What should I order in the Noggin Room?
Staffords seafood chowder to start, then the pub menu: a burger or sandwich at the bar under the Perry Hotels porch, with live music in summer. It is the locals room, so the regulars menu is the right menu.
Is Kilwins really from Petoskey?
Yes. Kilwins was founded in Petoskey in 1947, its Heritage Chocolate is still made in its Petoskey chocolate kitchen, and the Howard Street shop sells fudge made in the stores open kitchen, ice cream and caramel apples.
When is cherry season?
July is the heart of it in northwestern Michigan. Morels come earlier, in spring, and apples close the year in autumn. Outside their weeks, all three appear preserved in the pies, jams and menus of the Petoskey kitchens.
Photo: A dining room at the Hotel Perry, Petoskey, set for dinner with a view toward Little Traverse Bay. Photo from Hotel Perry, official website.


